Thursday, March 13, 2008

Ms. vs Cosmopolitan: importance of magazines in womens lives today




This week I am focusing on girl’s magazines and the effect on women that they have. We are going to compare cosmopolitan with Ms. Magazine. We don’t want to judge a book by its cover but in this case does that rule apply? Let us look at the main articles the cover shows. In cosmopolitans cover they want to tell you 50 things guys wish you knew as well as how to be a sex genius! In Ms. they want to tell you how important oil is to women as well as talk about crime in Darfur.
According to Helen Gurley Brown, the editor in chief and brains behind cosmopolitan, the magazine is supposed to reach out to that single young working woman. According to an article I read called Inventing the Cosmo Girl “expenditure s on clothing, cosmetics, and accessories were presented as necessary investments in the construction of a desirable (and thus saleable) self. “Basically, you should dress up and look good in order to hook that man. From what it looks like, Cosmopolitan basically creates a culture of “pink collar” working women who should be very materialistic and sexually active.
Ms. On the other hand is a magazine that stays away from the path of consumerism but rather focuses on day to day issues that women deal with pretty much to a feministic point of view. According to the website, it was the first to “Ms. was the first U.S. magazine to feature prominent American women demanding the repeal of laws that criminalized abortion, the first to explain and advocate for the ERA, to rate presidential candidates on women's issues, to put domestic violence and sexual harassment on the cover of a women's magazine, to feature feminist protest of pornography, to commission and feature a national study on date rape, and to blow the whistle on the undue influence of advertising on magazine journalism” Gloria Steinem was interviewed and she talked about why they were careful with what advertisements they wanted and didn’t want. She says “the most important reason was keeping the price of a feminist magazine low enough for most women to afford. But the second and almost equal reason was providing a forum where women and advertisers could talk to each other and improve advertising itself.” Which magazine do you think people should read more?
Who wins? Ms. takes the trophy today.

No comments: